Templin Forestry Inc.
150 Kincaid Lane Boyce, Louisiana 71409

Line

Phone: (318) 445-5566 Fax: (318) 445-4422 E-Mail

Land Owner Leader
Vol. 9 No. 2 Fall, 1998

The Value of a Consulting Forester

In free markets, money is a useful measure of comparing the value of goods and services. Although it is simply a measure or symbol of value, it is an appropriate measure when deciding to use any service. Getting the best price for timber is only one element of managing timber and just one part of managing a sale. However, price is a measure everyone understands when making judgements. Can a consulting forester get you the very best price for your timber? This article attempts to help you answer that question.

Most of our clients believe that one of our greatest contributions to them is our marketing skill when it comes to selling timber and land. The results are generally a reflection of our intent and the comprehensive disciplined approach we use to serve our clients. Our timber marketing style and expertise generally result in prices that are the top of the market at any point in time. I have compared our timber sales with the averages reported by the Louisiana Office of Forestry since 1979. We consistently have obtained an average price 23% more for our clients than the state averages. The margins were larger when markets were improving and smaller when markets were declining.

A number of studies have found that landowners get significantly better prices for their timber if they use professional forestry assistance. The most detailed study I have found is one conducted by Ian A. Munn at Mississippi State University and E. Carlyle Franklin at North Carolina State University. They compared timber sale income received by landowners who used consulting foresters with the income to landowners who used "free" forestry services of industry sponsored Landowner Assistance Programs (LAP) or those offered by state and extension services. The study used 298 timber sales: 105 sales were handled by consulting foresters and 193 were non-consultant sales. After making adjustments for timber volumes, quality, and a number of other considerations, they found that landowners using consulting foresters received 20% more income per thousand board feet than the landowners who used the free forestry services available to them. This is well above the rates consulting foresters charge for their services. I found this research conclusion to be interesting and thought provoking. If you call or write, I will be happy to supply you with a copy of this report.

There is a combination of factors at work that would result in these findings. While free forestry advice from any source is certainly helpful in most cases, a consulting forester has no conflict of interest to impede his desire to serve his client. He joins with his client with the intent to serve him to the best of his ability. For a number of reasons, that conviction is not found in the free forestry services offered to landowners. The higher prices consulting foresters get for their clients are basically a reflection of the joining together in intent. We concentrate on the process of each task given to us, whether it's conducting a sale, planting a tree, preparing an appraisal or writing a forest management plan. Accuracy and completeness in each task is our methodology, but I believe that aligning our priorities with those of our clients is the real reason that the results end up being favorable to all concerned.

Free professional forestry advice is generally more helpful than none at all. Service foresters play a significant role to landowners in education and can help in marketing efforts for landowners who have tracts too small to engage the services of a consulting forester. However, a consulting forester who joins with his client with no underlying conflict in thought or desire will provide the forestry marketing services in a manner that brings the best results for his clients.

 

Stumpage Market Report

Prices for timber took a downturn in March and April and have not yet recovered. Although a number of factors are at work, the greatest has been the effect of the "Asian Flu." Japan is the largest importer of lumber and logs in the world. Much of the production in the Northwest and Canada went to Japan before they began having such economic difficulties. This year, the production from the Northwest is competing with production in the South for domestic use of timber products. Fortunately, our economy is strong, with great domestic markets for housing, low interest and inflation, high employment, and a balanced budget. However, the high domestic demand for timber products is matched with high supply. Therefore, the prices for lumber and plywood have not been very strong this year.

Local factors affecting the stumpage markets include the windstorm in February, 1998, that blew down so much timber in East Texas. The USFS has been salvaging a million board feet of pine sawtimber a day. Much of the salvage timber has been coming into mills in Louisiana. The salvage work is beginning to slow down and will come to an end this fall as the downed trees are beginning to lose weight and decay. The worst drought in Louisiana's history has affected every living thing. My heart goes out to the farmers. Many of the trees planted last winter succumbed to the drought. It is amazing that any of them survived. Timber operators have been able to harvest timber in places that are normally too wet, allowing mills to have an abundant supply of timber this year. Plum Creek closed their plywood plant in Joyce and are in the midst of constructing a state-of-the-art sawmill that will use smaller logs. Willamette's plywood plant in Zwolle is back on-line after a fire closed them down earlier this year. Boise Cascade is closing their sawmill at Fisher.

We are beginning to see some renewed interest by the mills in pine sawtimber. I expect that the prices will improve this winter and spring. It may be a while before they reach the highs we saw last year. Japan will have to bite the bullet, much as we did in the Reagan years, in order to cure their economy. It will take them several years to work out of their financial problems.

I expect timber markets to improve somewhat during 1999 - 2000. The thing that timber sellers must keep in mind is that we have a strong domestic economy. I have seen bad times as well as good ones and can tell you that the best time for selling timber is when our economy is strong. The best advice I can give you is to consult your trusted forest advisor to help guide you in the present and give you a clear direction for the future in managing your timber.

OSB and plywood prices in August improved to nearly all-time highs. There have also been some recent improvements in the prices for lumber that occurred early in the 3rd quarter of this year. Production of lumber and panels has been relatively high, close to last year's record production.

 

* Compiled by Templin Forestry from Random Lengths

** Templin Forestry

Hardwood sawtimber prices were excellent this spring and early summer. Prices have waned some since then but demand for furniture is strong. I expect the hardwood sawtimber markets to gradually improve this next year. The pine pulpwood markets have been pretty good this year. Hardwood pulpwood prices have been terrible, if you could get the timber sold at all. The markets for hardwood pulpwood will probably continue to be depressed throughout the next year or two due to the weak markets in Asia. Strong domestic consumption of paper products has helped the paper companies this year.

The average pine stumpage prices received in the last eighteen months by our clients as compared with the average prices reported by the state are shown in the graph below. Don’t think your timber should necessarily bring the prices shown here. The value of your timber depends on a variety of factors, not the least of which is professional representation when selling timber.

*  Published by the Louisiana Office of Forestry

Information and Action Lead to Higher Timber Profits

If you are a person who wants to maximize income from your forest, you have an opportunity and an invitation to attend a dinner meeting on Thursday, October 8, 1998 at the Holiday Inn on MacArthur Drive, Alexandria, Louisiana from 6 to 8:30 p.m. The program is entitled "Maximizing Profits for Forest Landowners." Clients and prospective clients are encouraged to attend. The buffet dinner and program are free and open to the public, but RSVP is necessary so we can plan the number of meals. Please join us for an informative and delightful evening.

I will discuss Louisiana "Timber Markets - Past, Present & Future." I'll show you where we are and give my candid opinions of what to expect from the markets during the next few years. Mark Thomas, Business Relations Manager with American Cyanamid, will discuss the modern forest management technology available to private landowners and how they can position themselves for greater profits from timber management. His talk is entitled "Innovations in Southern Silviculture." Mark is entertaining and informative. I guarantee that you will learn something from attending this meeting that will help you realize greater profits from managing your timber.

 If you wish to attend the meeting Maximizing Profits for Forest Landowners, please cut off this portion of the page, fill it out, and send it to Templin Forestry, Inc., 150 Kincaid Lane, Boyce, Louisiana 71409 or you may call us at (318) 445-5566 and be sure to let us know how many people will join you.

Yes, I intend to come to the meeting entitled Maximizing Profits for Forest Landowners on October 8, 1998, from 6 - 8:30 p.m. at the Holiday Inn on MacArthur Drive, Alexandria, Louisiana.

I intend to bring ____________ people with me.

 

Real Estate Page

We have an excellent tract of land for sale in Grant Parish, Louisiana. This 183 acres of land has frontage along US Highway 71 and LA 471. The timber on it is comprised of large pine pulpwood that has recently been thinned and is poised to leap into the sawtimber product class during the next few years. This property is highly desirable. Lump sum, sealed bids for the property will be taken at 3:00 p.m. on Thursday, September 24, 1998. Call us for a complete prospectus for the property.

We are working on a few more excellent land sales that we hope to have later this year. If you wish to be placed on our buyers' list, please call us so we can inform you of the properties that interest you. Whether you are buying or selling, it is worth the time to call us.

 

Line
Tempin Forestry Home Page - E-Mail Templin Forestry -
Prepared by BTech Design